• Beta
Managing Piping - Pipe vs Piping System
  • 28 Nov 2024
  • 2 Minutes to read
  • Contributors
  • Dark
    Light
  • PDF

Managing Piping - Pipe vs Piping System

  • Dark
    Light
  • PDF

Article summary

Piping System Theory

In Piping Systems - Overview, we mentioned that a Piping System is a type of FLOC/Equipment that is used to group together pieces of Pipe/Piping in much the same way that Corrosion Loops are used to group together piping and Equipment subjected to the same degradation mechanisms.

However, Piping Systems are used to define a group of pipe/piping from one piece of Equipment to another within a Corrosion Loop.

Comparison of Approaches to Managing Pipe

Three of the main approaches to managing Piping in Piping Systems:

  • Pipe/Piping grouped by Corrosion Loop.

    • All Pipe/Piping in a specific Corrosion Loop (or process area within a Unit) is managed together.

  • Pipe/Piping grouped by Piping System.

    • Pipe/Piping extending from one piece of Equipment to another are grouped together. This approach is described in the S-RBI for Pressure Vessels and Piping Recommend Practice document. See the Piping System Hierarchy example below.

  • Pipe/Piping managed at Pipe Tag level.

    • Each piece of Pipe/Piping is managed as a distinct entity.

Some of the advantages and disadvantages of each of the approaches are identified in the Table below.

Management Approach

Advantages

Disadvantages

Corrosion Loop

  • Easier to optimize for external inspection.

  • Might be a viable solution for assets with simple processes or predominantly corrosion resistant alloy piping (e.g. upstream platforms or trading & supply terminals).

  • Inspection strategy needs to be clear for the entire loop

  • Several materials and degradation might exist, criticality and risk can change dramatically within the same loop.

  • CMLs might not provide a representative sample of corrosion issues.

  • Analysis might require more time to understand localized corrosion issues.

Piping System

  • Compared to individual pipe tags, fewer Circuits and Schedules to manage.

  • Circuits and Components have a 1-1 relationship; Calculated corrosion rates, corrosion allowance and Remnant Life can be used as inputs into RBI analysis.

  • RBI analysis results can be applied to Circuits for Thinning (age-related Damage Mechanisms).

  • Effective way to manage inspections schedules.

  • Piping FLOCs and Equipment may not directly represent other data sources, e.g. 3D model.

Pipe Tag

  • Very granular approach to managing piping integrity

  • Might be better aligned with other data sources, e.g. 3D models.

  • Unmanageable number of Inspections Schedules and SAP Work Orders.

  • Large number of default Schedules will be created

  • Difficult to align with RBI, results in more Components than are needed.

  • Results in many more Circuits and Corrosion Schedules than are needed for corrosion rate determination.

Piping System Hierarchy Example

To illustrate how a Piping System might be implemented, the hypothetical System illustrated below shows Corrosion Loop CL01 which extends from FLOC V-100 to V-110 containing two separate Piping Systems:

  • P100-CL01-001 containing Pipe and related Equipment extending from V-100 to E-100, and,

  • P100-CL01-002 containing Pipe and related Equipment extending from E-100 to V-110.

image.png

Example of Corrosion Loop Containing two Piping Systems.

 For the example above, the hierarchy of Piping System P100-CL01-001 could look something like the following.

Example of a Piping System hierarchy.

To learn how to create a Piping System in IMS, see: Creating Piping Systems.


Was this helpful? Click to add feedback comments

Changing your password will log you out immediately. Use the new password to log back in.
First name must have atleast 2 characters. Numbers and special characters are not allowed.
Last name must have atleast 1 characters. Numbers and special characters are not allowed.
Enter a valid email
Enter a valid password
Your profile has been successfully updated.
ESC

Eddy AI, facilitating knowledge discovery through conversational intelligence